New companies added every week. Free for practices.

PracticeVendors

Medical Billing Audit: What It Covers and When Your Practice Needs One

What a medical billing audit checks, how often federal guidance suggests auditing, how many records to review, what to do about overpayments, and what to ask an audit company.

Key Takeaways

  • A billing audit compares claims with medical records and checks coding, documentation, charge capture, denials, A/R and payments.
  • OIG guidance suggests a baseline audit, then periodic audits at least once a year (65 FR 59434).
  • A basic sample is five or more records per federal payer, or five to ten records per physician.
  • Medicare and Medicaid overpayments must be reported and returned within 60 days after they are identified (42 CFR 401.305).

A medical billing audit checks whether the claims your practice sends match the care that was documented, and whether the money owed to you is actually being collected. It is the one review that catches coding errors, missed charges and overpayments before a payer does. This guide explains what an audit covers, how often federal guidance suggests doing one, how big the sample should be, and what to ask an outside auditor.

What a Billing Audit Covers

The HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG), in its compliance guidance for individual and small group physician practices, describes two kinds of review: a review of the practice’s written standards and procedures, and a claims submission audit that compares bills with medical records (65 FR 59434). Most outside audits today cover both, plus the revenue side.

Area What is checked What it finds
Coding accuracy CPT, HCPCS and ICD-10 codes against the documentation in each sampled record Undercoding, overcoding, wrong modifiers, unsupported codes
Documentation Whether notes support the level of service and medical necessity Missing elements that put payments at risk on review
Charge capture Visits and procedures in the schedule against claims actually billed Services delivered but never billed
Denials and A/R Denial reasons, appeals, aging balances and write-offs Money that was owed but not collected
Payments Payer payments against contracted rates Underpayments, and overpayments that must be returned
Policies Written billing and coding procedures Rules that are outdated or not followed

How Often to Audit

The OIG guidance suggests starting with a baseline audit, a snapshot of how claims are developed and submitted from patient intake through payment, and then running periodic audits at least once a year to confirm the process is being followed (65 FR 59434). If an audit finds problems, the guidance says a practice should consider a focused review on a more frequent basis.

Many practices also order an audit at specific moments: before or after switching billing companies, when a new provider joins, when denials rise for no clear reason, or before signing a new payer contract.

How Many Records to Review

Per federal payer

  • Five or more medical records for each federal payer, such as Medicare and Medicaid

Per physician

  • Five to ten medical records for each physician
The OIG calls these a basic guide, not a set formula. A larger sample gives more confidence in the results (65 FR 59434).

How the Sample Is Chosen

The guidance describes two common ways to pick claims (65 FR 59434):

  • Random sample from all claims a physician was paid for, or from all claims for one payer.
  • Risk-based sample drawn only from codes linked to known risk areas, such as high-level visit codes or procedures that are often denied.

A good auditor explains which method was used and why, so the next audit can be compared with this one.

What Happens if the Audit Finds Money You Owe

Audits sometimes find that a payer paid too much. For Medicare and Medicaid, federal rules require a provider to report and return an overpayment within 60 days after it is identified, and a provider has identified an overpayment once it knowingly receives or keeps one (42 CFR 401.305). The deadline can be paused while the practice carries out a timely, good faith investigation. This is why audit findings should go to someone who can act on them quickly, not sit in a report.

Internal Review or Outside Auditor

The OIG guidance suggests that self-audits include the person in charge of billing and a medically trained person, ideally a physician. Many small practices do not have the time or a certified coder on staff, so they use an outside audit company. An outside auditor also brings a view that is independent of the people who did the billing, which matters most when the audit is checking your current billing company’s work.

Questions to Ask an Audit Company

  1. Who reviews the records? Ask for their coding certifications, such as CPC from AAPC or CCS from AHIMA.
  2. How will you choose the sample, and how many records per provider and payer?
  3. Will you check coding only, or also charge capture, denials, A/R and payments against our contracts?
  4. What does the report include? Ask for findings by provider, the dollar impact, and clear next steps.
  5. Will you walk us through the results and train our staff or billing company on the fixes?
  6. If you find overpayments, how will you document them so we can return them on time?

Compare billing audit companies in the directory, or describe what you need and get matched. To track results month to month after the audit, see which billing reports to ask for, and for common denial patterns, our claim denials guide.

Common Questions

What does a medical billing audit check?

It compares claims with medical records to check coding and documentation, and usually also reviews charge capture, denials, A/R, write-offs and payments against payer contracts.

How often should a practice audit its billing?

OIG guidance for physician practices suggests a baseline audit and then periodic audits at least once a year, with more frequent focused reviews if problems are found.

How many records should a billing audit review?

OIG calls it a basic guide, not a formula: five or more records per federal payer, or five to ten records per physician. A larger sample gives more confidence.

What if an audit finds an overpayment?

For Medicare and Medicaid, the provider must report and return it within 60 days after it is identified. The deadline can pause during a timely, good faith investigation.

Sources

  1. OIG Compliance Program for Individual and Small Group Physician Practices, 65 FR 59434 (Federal Register)
  2. 42 CFR 401.305, requirements for reporting and returning of overpayments (eCFR)

Rules differ by payer, plan, state and contract, and they change. Confirm current requirements with the payer or agency before you act.

ShareLinkedInFacebookEmail

This guide is general information for US medical practices, not legal, financial or compliance advice. Found something out of date? Email info@practicevendors.com and we will correct it.

More Guides

All guides